Skip to Main Content

General Nursing Research Guide

Peer Review

 

Peer Review Definition: The evaluation of scientific, academic, or professional work by others working in the same field

  • Typically written by professors, scholars, professional researchers or experts in the field
  • Before publication, articles are scrutinized by other experts in the same field (that's why it's called "peer review")
  • Peer-review articles are considered to be among the most authoritative and reliable sources you can choose for your research paper or project, because of the rigorous review process
  • Peer reviewed articles usually have a narrow focus, and often report the results of a research study. Often, they can provide excellent examples or case studies to support the arguments or explanations within your research paper

 

 

Google Scholar VS. Library Databases

For this particular assignment, we are asking that you don't use Google Scholar. While Google Scholar can seem like a good resource, it is problematic as a 'research' tool. Please see the chart to below to see the differences between Google Scholar and Library Databases.

Google Scholar Library Databases
Uses numerous factors to determine your search results, including your previous search history and current location Ranks search results by relevancy of the search terms entered, and any applied filters
Does not have filters or a way to narrow down your search results Numerous filters can be applied to refine your search results
Very few full text articles. Mainly abstracts, and lots of paywalls Access to thousands of full text articles, and free to Linfield students
Articles may not be 'scholarly'. You'll need to evaluate each source for yourself Can filter to 'peer reviewed' articles. Content is from vetted sources
Does not clearly specify what type of material (academic journal, print book, newspaper) is in the results list  Allows users to sort results by material type